Anime series have a vast following, boasting dedicated fans who generate significant buzz. However, there are instances when the excitement surrounding an anime overshadows its actual quality, leading to what’s commonly known as an overhyped series.
Popular shows like Sword Art Online, Tokyo Ghoul, and Attack on Titan have faced criticism from both fans and critics for not living up to the high expectations they’ve garnered. While these series have amassed enormous fan bases, they’ve also been scrutinized for issues such as pacing, storytelling, and character development, raising doubts about whether they truly justify the immense hype they receive.

Death Note
Death Note, a globally renowned anime, faced backlash for its second half after a major plot twist. Initially hailed for its intense psychological battles and unique premise, the latter episodes witnessed a shift in character dynamics, focus, and pacing.
Critics argue that these changes compromised the tightly woven narrative of the earlier episodes, resulting in an unsatisfying conclusion. Nevertheless, Death Note continues to be a well-recognized anime, though many fans believe that the second half didn’t meet the overwhelming hype.
- Advertisement -
One-Punch Man
One-Punch Man is celebrated for its distinctive concept, humor, and top-notch animation quality. Season 2 was eagerly awaited following the success of the first season. However, a change in production studios led to a noticeable drop in animation quality in Season 2, disappointing many fans.
Furthermore, some viewers felt that the increased focus on secondary characters at the expense of the protagonist, Saitama, diluted the show’s unique charm. Many fans argue that the second season failed to maintain the hype and high standards set by its predecessor.
My Hero Academia
My Hero Academia is a popular superhero-themed anime that generated immense hype due to its compelling characters, the concept of a superhero society, and visually stunning battles. However, critics contend that the series relies too heavily on established shounen tropes, resulting in a formulaic and predictable narrative.
Some fans have also criticized the lack of character development for its extensive cast. Despite these criticisms, My Hero Academia retains a significant fanbase who find enjoyment in its vibrant world. The debate over whether its hype matches its quality continues among anime enthusiasts.
Boruto: Naruto Next Generations
Boruto: Naruto Next Generations serves as a sequel to the acclaimed Naruto series, sparking significant anticipation. However, some fans feel it lacks the depth and focus of the original, leading to the perception of being overhyped. Critics often point to excessive filler content and the underdevelopment of older characters as shortcomings.
- Advertisement -
Even with a promising new generation of ninjas and the continuation of the beloved ninja world, many believe that Boruto falls short of the high standards set by Naruto, failing to justify the initial excitement within the anime community.
Fairy Tail
Fairy Tail is a long-running magic anime that cultivated a devoted fanbase thanks to its vibrant world, exciting magic battles, and the camaraderie within the Fairy Tail guild. However, the series has been criticized for its limited character development, repetitive plotlines, and inconsistent handling of its magic system.
Moreover, the series’ frequent reliance on the power of friendship as a plot resolution has been deemed predictable by critics. While Fairy Tail certainly has its moments and memorable characters, many argue that it doesn’t live up to its considerable hype.
- Advertisement -
Dragon Ball Super
Dragon Ball Super brought the beloved Dragon Ball franchise back to the screen, generating immense excitement among fans. However, the show received criticism for inconsistent animation quality, recycled plotlines, and less engaging story arcs.
The series leaned heavily on nostalgia and failed to introduce new and exciting elements. Despite featuring fan-favorite characters and continuing the saga of Goku and his friends, many viewers argue that Dragon Ball Super fell short of its hype, failing to match the original series in terms of quality.
Naruto Series
Naruto and its sequel, Naruto: Shippuden, are globally renowned Shonen anime series celebrated for their world-building, character depth, and emotional story arcs. Nevertheless, they’ve faced criticism for their excessive filler episodes, which disrupted pacing and narrative flow.
While Naruto has made a significant impact, some fans believe that certain plotlines remained unresolved, leading to dissatisfaction. However, the extensive hype has led some fans to argue that the actual quality of the series doesn’t always meet the high expectations set by its popularity.
Attack On Titan
Attack on Titan is an anime known for its intense, grim atmosphere, intricate world-building, and shocking plot twists. The series garnered immense hype, but some viewers criticize its slow pacing in earlier seasons and abrupt tonal shifts.
Many feel the heavy exposition and complex plot can be challenging to follow, reducing the emotional impact of key events. Nevertheless, Attack on Titan remains popular, even though debates continue about whether its complexity and pacing truly justify the high level of hype it has received.
Tokyo Ghoul
Tokyo Ghoul is a dark fantasy anime that attracted substantial attention with its unique premise and compelling characters. However, after a promising first season, later seasons, particularly Tokyo Ghoul:re, were criticized for rushed pacing and convoluted storytelling, diverging significantly from the source manga.
This often left viewers feeling confused and unsatisfied. Despite its intriguing concept of a world where ghouls and humans coexist, many fans argue that Tokyo Ghoul’s execution did not live up to the considerable hype it received, making it a subject of debate.
Sword Art Online
Sword Art Online captivated audiences with its compelling premise of players trapped in a virtual reality game. However, despite a promising start, it’s often criticized for its inconsistent pacing, lack of character development, and plot contrivances in later arcs.
The perceived drop in narrative quality made many viewers feel the series wasn’t fulfilling its potential. While Sword Art Online maintains a large fanbase that enjoys its blend of action, romance, and fantasy, its overall reception is mixed, with many arguing that the show doesn’t match the high level of hype.